From Trash
to Schmaltz
Rich and Famous was a commercial
failure when it was released in 1981, but that didn’t stop Disney’s Touchstone Pictures
from peddling the same story seven years later when it released Beaches
in 1988.
Though the two
films have the shared theme of an enduring friendship forged between opposites,
they do have some key differences. The friends in Rich and Famous are on
a level playing field, both being attractive, privileged women (Merry might be
the rich one, but apparently there is considerable cash to be made writing
magazine think pieces, judging by Liz’s a picturesque riverside farmhouse in
Connecticut). In Beaches, the friendship is between the tough-talking, working-class
C.C. Bloom (Bette Midler) and the conventionally attractive, wealthy WASP Hillary
(Barbara Hershey). In Rich and Famous, Liz and Merry are in competition with each other in the world of publishing, whereas in Beaches C.C.
is an entertainer and Hillary is an attorney. The biggest difference of all: Rich
and Famous ends with a gay panic joke; Beaches ends with the death
of one of its main characters. I would apologize for the spoiler, but the movie
pretty much gives it away in the first 10 minutes, when C.C.’s concert
rehearsal at the Hollywood Bowl is interrupted with the news that Hillary is in
the hospital.
 |
Before she was Blossom or annoying, Mayim Bialik killed it as Lil’ C.C. in Beaches. |
Beaches’ central friendship also begins in the late 1950s, when a lost 11-year-old Hillary,
played by Marcie Leeds, vacationing in Atlantic City with her family, meets 11-year-old C.C.,
played by Miyam “Ask
me about my Ph.D. in neuroscience!” Bialik (in fairness, while Bialik is kind of
annoying today, she is pretty great in this early role). Hillary is fascinated
by this brash girl she meets under the Boardwalk, and C.C. is eager to please
her new fan. Even though the girls live on different coasts, they maintain
their friendship through frequent letters (the Iris Rainer-Dart novel on which
Beaches is based tells much of its story through the main characters’
letters).
 |
Too bad he’s not a furry: John Pierce (John Heard) is more into Hillary at first meeting. |
Their friendship is
tested in adulthood, especially whenever the two women are in the same room
together. They’re all squeals and hugs in the late 1960s, when they share a
cramped New York walk-up, C.C. singing in dive bars and delivering/performing
singing telegrams and Hillary working for the ACLU. Their friendship becomes
strained, however, when they fall for the same man, theater director John
Pierce (the late John Heard).
 |
| She’ll cut a bitch. |
 |
Not pictured: Barbara Hershey and Bette Midler |
The film settles
into a pattern: C.C. and Hillary reunite, resume their friendship, then
fight/separate abruptly. Along the way the women marry—C.C. to John; Hillary to
Michael Essex (James Read), a snooty attorney who is most definitely not
a fan of his wife’s tacky friend—only to get divorced a few years later. C.C.
finally achieves her dream of stardom, her bawdy musical revue making her the
toast of Broadway in the early 1970s, but near the decade’s end she’s hoping
recording a disco album will revive her flagging career (Beaches none
too subtly mimics the ups and downs of Midler’s own career). Disco can wait,
though, C.C. deciding to stick around in San Francisco to help Hillary through
her pregnancy (a parting gift from Michael). Things take a ridiculous turn when
C.C. begins dating Hillary’s OB/GYN (the late Spalding Gray), uncharacteristically
considering abandoning show business to become his wife. That is, until she
gets a call from her agent about a part in a play that’s perfect for her. She abruptly leaves for New York—and leaves Hillary to break the bad news to her
doctor. “He’d take it coming from you,” C.C. says. “He’s your gynecologist!”
 |
| Hillary questions C.C.’s choices, but not that hair. |
Hillary returns to
practicing law, balancing her career and motherhood, much easier to do when you’re
already rich. But then she’s diagnosed with viral cardiomyopathy, a condition
that, though fatal, ensures Hillary will remain looking lovely on her way out.
Cue “Wind Beneath My Wings.”
 |
| It’s titled Beaches for a reason. |
 |
The Divine Miss M adds one more ballad to Beaches’ bestselling soundtrack. |
Though novelist Rainer-Dart
reportedly had Cher in mind when she conceived the character of C.C. (Cee Cee
in the book), the role is tailor made for Midler, who co-produced. The role not only shows
off Midler’s strengths as an entertainer, but it also provides her an opportunity to recycle
re-introduce past material, as she does when C.C. performs the ditty “Otto
Titsling,” originally featured on Midler’s 1985 comedy album Mud
will be Flung Tonight. Hershey is good, too, counterbalancing Midler’s flamboyance
with a relatively restrained performance, but really, the part of Hillary could just as
well be credited as The Other One (Hershey got more publicity for getting collagen
lip injections for the film than she did for her performance
in it). This is Bette’s show.
 |
Beaches was remade in 2017
as a Lifetime TV movie, starring Idina Menzel and Nia Long, retroactively making
the 1988 original look like Terms of Endearment. Menzel and Long do
all right with what they’re given, and the script even improves on the original
slightly by eliminating that romance between C.C. and Hillary’s gynecologist,
but otherwise it’s about what you would expect.
Which is to say: don’t bother. |
Beaches was a box office
hit when it was released in 1988, solidifying Midler’s status as a movie star.
Its soundtrack was an even bigger hit, reviving Midler’s then dormant singing
career. I love Midler, so much that I saw Jinxed! during its theatrical
run and liked it (c’mon, she’s done much, much worse). Yet even though it’s
one of Midler’s better movies, Beaches is not a favorite. Director Garry
Marshall adeptly balances the comedy and drama, but the laughs are mild—I
laughed harder and more often watching Rich and Famous—and the drama hollow. Marshall’s
roots in TV sit-coms are quite apparent, the result being that Beaches
has more in common with A Very Special Episode than a big screen dramedy, with
all the edges sanded down for a wide audience. This reputed weepie failed to
jerk a single tear from my eyes, probably because I’m dead inside, but I also blame
it on the fact that many of Beaches’ emotional beats feel manipulative. Rich
and Famous may be trash, but Beaches is schmaltz.
Another reason I’m
not a huge fan of Beaches has nothing to do with the movie itself, but
what it represents. It’s a demarcation line in Midler’s career, when she went
from being that raucous performer adored by your gay uncle to that sappy
balladeer your mom likes (mitigating factor: by 1988, your gay uncle was probably
dead). Instead of growing Midler settled. While there have been high points along the way, she spent the majority of her post-Beaches career making saccharine dramedies (Stella;
For the Boys) and comedies of varying (some would say diminishing) quality, the best of which being
her 1996 hit The First Wives Club, though even that movie falls short of
its potential, Olivia Goldsmith’s novel being transformed from dark revenge fantasy to
frothy—and toothless—romp. The Divine Miss M persona Midler had crafted throughout
the ’70s only got trotted out for unsuspecting moms during live performances. Consequently, millennials
likely only know her as the singer of “Wind Beneath My Wings” and star of Hocus Pocus. For Gen Z, she’s just
another boomer celebrity tweeting
herself into hot water.
Beaches may be the more successful ’80s movie about female friendship, but it’s the ’70s-style trashiness of Rich
and Famous that I always return to. Love the Beaches soundtrack,
though.
 |
Candice Bergen and Bette Midler have each starred in
more recent movies about life-long friendships among women, now a staple in the SCAPT subgenre. Book Club was enjoyable, but its sequel, Book Club: The Next Chapter, was fucking painful. I haven’t seen The Fabulous Four yet, but the reviews have not been glowing.
|